Thursday, March 25, 2010

Could Rome have risen to power without slavery?

Romans relied on slaves for all of their work. To the Romans, it was if someone else could do the work instead of themselves, that’s how they would have it. All farm work was done by the slaves and it was a luxury to the Romans. Although Rome had a vast amount of power, the rapid attainment of slavery in Sicily almost tore the empire apart. War had broken out because of the slaves. This caused free men to not even want to fight with them, having weak armies between the two opposing armies. Not only could Rome have risen to power without slaves, they could potentially have been better off without them.

Sixty years after the Carthaginian Collapse, the Servile War broke out in Sicily. It all started because Sicily had rapidly acquired great fortunes and wealth, so they used the money to buy slaves. The slaves were given the bare minimum in food, clothing, shelter, and water. They rarely took care of the slaves, and they were often sick. To the Romans, the slaves were simply an object. They were beaten, cursed at, and spat on. It had gotten to the point in which the slaves could no longer take it. They had random meetings when the opportunity arose, and planned their revolt. When this happened, armies were sent out against them. The slaves were easily beaten in this battle because some just did not have the energy to fight from their lack of food provided. It has been reported that 450 slaves were crucified at Minturnae and 4,000 slaves were crushed by military officers. (Diodorus Siculus)

There was another murder of Pedanius Secundus in 61 AD. He was killed by one of his slaves because the slave had been refused freedom after paying the correct amount to be freed. It is said that when this happens, everyone living under the same roof is to be put to death. This had plebs outraged and many of them fought for the lives on the innocent that were to be put to death. This condition had been put before the council and one councilman, Gaius Cassius, argued in favoring the slaves. He had said that people should have understood why the other slaves had acted this way, saying they did not know anything about the murder. One main thing this man said was that, “After we started to have entire nations as household slaves, people who had different customs, different faiths, if any, you were not able to control this cesspool in any way other than through fear.” He basically had said that there had been no indication that any other slaves had known what was going on. Therefore, it was not the other slaves fault. (Tacitus)

The Romans depended on more slaves than any other country in the Mediterranean. Because of the higher number, that gave greater risk for the revolts of slavery. As seen in the two examples above, the slaves will revolt in either big groups like in Sicily, or just one slave doing the same amount of damage like in the death of Pedanius Secundus in Rome. It is estimated that there were about two million slaves in a population of about six million by the reign of Augustus in the city of Rome, making the slaves one third of the population. An estimate of the whole empire during this time is nearly impossible to calculate. Slaves came from all over the place, from war to the captured Liberians. Many slaves were almost no use to the Roman armies because they lacked energy, and the tactical smarts to maneuver within the armies. (John Madden)

Although Rome rose to power during these periods of slavery, they could have done it easily without them. The slaves were there just to work in households and farms, as if there for extra assistance. It was the armies and government that brought Rome to power, not its use of slavery. Rome could have potentially also been better off without them, no longer having to worry about a slavery revolt.

Primary Source:
Diodorus Siculus - Books 34/35 "Internet Ancient History Sourcebook: Rome." FORDHAM.EDU. Web. 25 Mar. 2010. http://www.fordham.edu/halsall/ancient/asbook09.html#Slavery

Tacitus - The murder of Pedanius Secundus "Internet Ancient History Sourcebook: Rome." FORDHAM.EDU. Web. 25 Mar. 2010. http://www.fordham.edu/halsall/ancient/asbook09.html#Slavery

"Internet Ancient History Sourcebook: Rome." FORDHAM.EDU. Web. 25 Mar. 2010. http://www.fordham.edu/halsall/ancient/asbook09.html#Slavery

Picture Sources:
"Slavery, Rome & The Internet ." Rosenblum TV. Web. 25 Mar. 2010. http://www.rosenblumtv.com/?p=3429
"Letter from America 6." Hornbill Unleashed. Web. 25 Mar. 2010. http://hornbillunleashed.wordpress.com/2009/05/30/1512/

No comments:

Post a Comment