Thursday, June 10, 2010

Exam Question 6

Question: What was the long range political impact of the reign of the Medici popes?

Thesis: The political impact of the Medici Popes is one of debt and they were unable to keep citizens calm. Pope Leo X is most remembered for his selling indulgences. Mostly, the Luthern church would begin as a result of his reign

Primary Source #1:

All Florence, then, as well as all the princes of Italy, lamented the death of Lorenzo; in proof of which there was not one who did not send ambassdors to Florence to express his grief at so great a loss. And events very soon after proved that they had just cause for their regrets; for Italy being deprived of Lorenzo's counsels, no means could be found to satisfy or check the ambition of Lodovico Sforza, governor of the Duke of Milan. From this, soon after Lorenzo's death, there began to spring up those evil seeds of trouble, which ruined and continue to cause the ruin of Italy, as there was no one capable of destroying them.

http://www.fordham.edu/Halsall/source/machiavelli-histflo-lorenzo.html

"Medieval Sourcebook: Niccolò Machiavelli: History of Florence: Lorence De' Medici."FORDHAM.EDU. Web. 10 June 2010.

Primary Source #2:

You are not only the youngest cardinal in the college, but the youngest person that ever was raised to that rank; and you ought, therefore, to be the most vigilant and unassuming, not giving others occasion to wait for you, either in the chapel, the consistory or upon deputations. You will soon get a sufficient insight into the manners of your brethren. With those of less respectable character converse not with too much intimacy; not merely on account of the circumstance in itself, but for the sake of public opinion. Converse on general topics with all. On public occasions, let your equipage and address be rather below than above mediocrity.

http://www.iclnet.org/pub/resources/text/wittenberg/melan/lifea-01.txt

"Medieval Sourcebook: Lorenzo De Medici: Paternal Advice To A Cardinal (C. 1491)."FORDHAM.EDU. Web. 10 June 2010.

Primary Source #3:

That venerable man, Martin

Luther, whilst he was yet with us, gave us reason to hope that he might

himself, narrate the story of his life, with the circumstances of' conflict

attending it; and this he would undoubtedly have accomplished, had he not been

so soon called out of this mortal existence, onto the eternal fellowship of

God, and of his children in heaven.

http://www.iclnet.org/pub/resources/text/wittenberg/melan/lifea-01.txt

Internet Christian Library. Web. 10 June 2010.

Argument:

The political impact was a great one because of the Medici Popes. In the short term, Lorenzo had numerous people follow him and loved him as a leader. In the long run, Giovanni managed to get the Church in horrible debt. I included the excerpt of from Martin Luther because it was because of Giovanni de Medici challenged him. Because of that, the Luther reformation accured.

Exam Question 5

Question: Were the Vikings "barbarians"?

Thesis: The Vikings were barbarians, destroying everything in their path regardless who it was, or what the intention was.

Primary Source #1:

The work of destruction which the first stream of Northmen wrought on the continent is told in words of despair in what is left of the Frankish Chronicles, for the pagan and greedy invaders seem to have singled out the monasteries for attack and must have destroyed most of the records of their own devastation. A Danish fleet appeared off Frisia in 810, and ten years later another reached the mouth of the Loire, but the systematic and persevering assault did not begin until about 835. From that date till the early years of the following century the Viking ships were almost annual visitors to the coasts and river valleys of Germany andGaul.

http://www.newadvent.org/cathen/11115b.htm

"CATHOLIC ENCYCLOPEDIA: Northmen (Vikings)." NEW ADVENT: Home. Web. 10 June 2010

Primary Source #2:
The Northmen came to Paris with 700 sailing ships, not counting those of smaller size which are commonly called barques. At one stretch the Seine was lined with the vessels for more than two leagues, so that one might ask in astonishment in what cavern the river had been swallowed up, since it was not to be seen. The second day after the fleet of the Northmen arrived under the walls of the city, Siegfried, who was then king only in name but who was in command of the expedition, came to the dwelling of the illustrious bishop. He bowed his head and said: "Gauzelin, have compassion on yourself and on your flock. We beseech you to listen to us, in order that you may escape death. Allow us only the freedom of the city. We will do no harm and we will see to it that whatever belongs either to you or to Odo shall be strictly respected." Count Odo, who later became king, was then the defender of the city. The bishop replied to Siegfried, "Paris has been entrusted to us by the Emperor Charles, who, after God, king and lord of the powerful, rules over almost all the world. He has put it in our care, not at all that the kingdom may be ruined by our misconduct, but that he may keep it and be assured of its peace. If, like us, you had been given the duty of defending these walls, and if you should have done that which you ask us to do, what treatment do you think you would deserve?" Siegfried replied. "I should deserve that my head be cut off and thrown to the dogs. Nevertheless, if you do not listen to my demand, on the morrow our war machines will destroy you with poisoned arrows. You will be the prey of famine and of pestilence and these evils will renew themselves perpetually every year." So saying, he departed and gathered together his comrades.

http://www.fordham.edu/halsall/source/843bertin.html

"Medieval Sourcebook: Three Sources on the Ravages of the Northmen in Frankland, C. 843 - 912."FORDHAM.EDU. Web. 10 June 2010.

Primary Source #3:

According to their custom the Northmen plundered eastern and western Frisia and burned down the town of Dordrecht, with two other villages, before the eyes of Lothair [The Emperor], who was then in the castle of Nimwegen, but could not punish the crime. The Northmen, with their boast filled with immense booty, including both men and goods, returned to their own country.At this same time, as no one can mention or hear without great sadness, the mother of all the churches, the basilica of the apostle Peter, was taken and plundered by the Moors, or Saracens, who had already occupied the region of Beneventum. The Saracens, moreover, slaughtered all the Christians whom they found outside the walls of Rome, either within or without this church. They also carried men and women away prisoners. They tore down, among many others, the altar of the blessed Peter, and their crimes from day to day bring sorrow to Christians. Pope Sergius departed life this year.

http://www.fordham.edu/halsall/source/xanten1.html

"Medieval Sourcebook: Annals of Xanten, 845-853." FORDHAM.EDU. Web. 10 June 2010. v

Argument:

The Vikings came into towns with no warning, slaughtering thousands of people just because they could. Often times they demanded rule of the town. If that was not granted, the town would simply be burnt. As it shows in the third primary source, Christians were a massive target of the Vikings. Churches were burnt to the ground without despair. In some cases, the Vikings even made their way to the New World.

Exam Question 4

Question: Describe the significance of the Battle of Tours.

Thesis: The significance of the Battle of Tours was a turning point for Christians in the battle against the Islam’s.

Primary Source #1:

At last night sundered the combatants. The Franks with misgivings lowered their blades, and beholding the numberless tents of the Arabs, prepared themselves for another battle the next day. Very early, when they issued from their retreat, the men of Europe saw the Arab tents ranged still in order, in the same place where they had set up their camp. Unaware that they were utterly empty, and fearful lest within the phalanxes of the Saracens were drawn up for combat, they sent out spies to ascertain the facts. These spies discovered that all the squadrons of the "Ishmaelites" had vanished. In fact, during the night they had fled with the greatest silence, seeking with all speed their home land. The Europeans, uncertain and fearful, lest they were merely hidden in order to come back [to fall upon them] by ambushments, sent scouting parties everywhere, but to their great amazement found nothing. Then without troubling to pursue the fugitives, they contented themselves with sharing the spoils and returned right gladly to their own country.

http://www.fordham.edu/halsall/source/732tours.html

"Medieval Sourcebook: Arabs, Franks, and the Battle of Tours, 732." FORDHAM.EDU. Web. 10 June 2010.

Primary Source #2:

Near the river Owar [Loire], the two great hosts of the two languages and the two creeds were set in array against each other. The hearts of Abderrahman, his captains and his men were filled with wrath and pride, and they were the first to begin to fight. The Moslem horsemen dashed fierce and frequent forward against the battalions of the Franks, who resisted manfully, and many fell dead on either side, until the going down of the sun. Night parted the two armies: but in the grey of the morning the Moslems returned to the battle. Their cavaliers had soon hewn their way into the center of the Christian host. But many of the Moslems were fearful for the safety of the spoil which they had stored in their tents, and a false cry arose in their ranks that some of the enemy were plundering the camp; whereupon several squadrons of the Moslem horsemen rode off to protect their tents. But it seemed as if they fled; and all the host was troubled. And while Abderrahman strove to check their tumult, and to lead them back to battle, the warriors of the Franks came around him, and he was pierced through with many spears, so that he died. Then all the host fled before the enemy, and many died in the flight. . . .

http://www.fordham.edu/halsall/source/arab-poitiers732.html

"Medieval Sourcebook: Anon Arab Chronicler: The Battle of Poitiers, 732." FORDHAM.EDU. Web. 10 June 2010.

Primary Source #3:

Oftentimes the adventure of amours and of war are more fortunate and marvellous than any man can think or wish. Truly this battle, the which was near to Poitiers in the fields of Beauvoir and Maupertuis, was right great and perilous, and many deeds of arms there was done the which all came not to knowledge. The fighters on both sides endured much pain: king John with his own hands did that day marvels in arms: he had an axe in his hands wherewith he defended himself and fought in the breaking of the press. Near to the king there was taken the earl of Tancarville, sir Jaques of Bourbon car] of Ponthieu, and the lord John of Artois earl of Eu, and a little above that under the banner of the captal of Buch was taken sir Charles of Artois and divers other knights and squires. The chase endured to the gates of Poitiers: there were many slain and beaten down, horse and man, for they of Poitiers closed their gates and would suffer none to enter; wherefore in the street before the gate was horrible murder, men hurt and beaten down....

http://www.fordham.edu/halsall/source/froissart1.html

"Medieval Sourcebook: Jean Froissart: On The Hundred Years War (1337-1453)."FORDHAM.EDU. Web. 10 June 2010.

Argument:

These primary sources show the Battle of Tours, and how the Islamic army considered this to be an easy battle. Because of this battle, The Franks were free from the Islamic invasions, and were no longer being pressed to convert to the Muslim religion. This battle also helped establish Frankish power in Western Europe.

Exam Question 3

Question: Who is a better model for modern historians: Herodotus or Thucydides? Why?

Thesis: Herodotus was a better model for modern historians because he was the one who first started collecting and organizing his materials.

Primary Source #1:

The customs which I know the Persians to observe are the following: they have no images of the gods, no temples nor altars, and consider the use of them a sign of folly. This comes, I think, from their not believing the gods to have the same nature with men, as the Greeks imagine. Their wont, however, is to ascend the summits of the loftiest mountains, and there to offer sacrifice to Zeus, which is the name they give to the whole circuit of the firmament. They likewise offer to the sun and moon, to the earth, to fire, to water, and to the winds. These are the only gods whose worship has come down to them from ancient times. At a later period they began the worship of Urania, which they borrowed from the Arabians and Assyrians. Mylitta is the name by which the Assyrians know this goddess, whom the Arabians call Alitta, and the Persians Mitra.

http://www.fordham.edu/halsall/ancient/herodotus-persians.html

"Ancient History Sourcebook: Herodotus: Customs of the Persians." FORDHAM.EDU. Web. 10 June 2010.

Primary Source #2:

It must not, however, be supposed that he was at any time a mere student. It is probable that from an early age his inquiring disposition led him to engage in travels, both in Greece and in foreign countries. He traversed Asia Minor and European Greece probably more than once; he visited all the most important islands of the Archipelago-Rhodes, Cyprus, Delos, Paros, Thasos, Samothrace, Crete, Samos, Cythera and Aegina. He undertook the long and perilous journey from Sardis to the Persian capital Susa, visited Babylon, Colchis, and the western shores of the Black Sea as far as the estuary of the Dnieper; he travelled in Scythia and in Thrace, visited Zante and Magna Graecia, explored the antiqmties of Tyre, coasted along the shores of Palestine, saw Ga~a, and made a long stay in Egypt. At the most moderate estimate, his travels covered a space of thirtyone degrees of longitude, or 1700 miles, and twentyfour of latitude, or nearly the same distance. At all the more interesting sites he took up his abode for a time; he examined, he inquired, he made measurements, he accumulated materials. Having in his mind the scheme of his great work, he gave ample time to the elaboration of all its parts, and took care to obtain by personal observation a full knowledge of the various countries.

http://www.fordham.edu/halsall/ancient/eb11-herodotus.html

"Ancient History Sourcebook: 11th Brittanica: Herodotus." FORDHAM.EDU. Web. 10 June 2010.

Primary Source #3:

These are the researches of Herodotus of Halicarnassus, which he publishes, in the hope of thereby preserving from decay the remembrance of what men have done, and of preventing the great and wonderful actions of the Greeks and the Barbarians from losing their due meed of glory; and withal to put on record what were their grounds of feuds. According to the Persians best informed in history, the Phoenicians began to quarrel. This people, who had formerly dwelt on the shores of the Erythraean Sea, having migrated to the Mediterranean and settled in the parts which they now inhabit, began at once, they say, to adventure on long voyages, freighting their vessels with the wares of Egypt and Assyria.

http://classics.mit.edu/Herodotus/history.1.i.html

"The Internet Classics Archive | The History of Herodotus by Herodotus." The Internet Classics Archive: 441 Searchable Works of Classical Literature. Web. 10 June 2010

Argument:

All of these primary sources tell us how Herodotus traveled to find his information. He was one to go out of his comfort zone, and created new forms of history. In many of his writings, Herodotus claims the he knows the information “personally” or that it is his “knowledge”. Many reporters of modern history prefer reading stories written in ways such as Herodotus wrote his.

Exam Question 2

Question: Do you think Alexander honestly felt like he was avenging Persian wrongs? Or was that just propaganda to mask his goal of conquest?

Thesis: Alexander the Great grew up wanting conquest, as well as wanting power.

Primary Source #1:

While he was yet very young, he entertained the ambassadors from the King of Persia, in the absence of his father, and entering much into conversation with them, gained so much upon them by his affability, and the questions he asked them, which were far from being childish or trifling (for he inquired of them the length of the ways, the nature of the road into inner Asia, the character of their king, how he carried himself to his enemies, and what forces he was able to bring into the field), that they were struck with admiration of him, and looked upon the ability so much famed of Philip to be nothing in comparison with the forwardness and high purpose that appeared thus early in his son. Whenever he heard Philip had taken any town of importance, or won any signal victory, instead of rejoicing at it altogether, he would tell his companions that his father would anticipate everything, and leave him and them no opportunities of performing great and illustrious actions

http://classics.mit.edu/Plutarch/alexandr.html

"The Internet Classics Archive | Alexander by Plutarch." The Internet Classics Archive: 441 Searchable Works of Classical Literature. Web. 10 June 2010.

Primary Source #2:

“[Alexander] was only twenty years old when he succeeded to the crown, and he found the kingdom torn into pieces by dangerous parties and implacable animosities. The barbarous nations, even those that bordered upon Macedonia, could not brook subjection, and they longed for their natural kings... Alexander was of opinion, that the only way to security, and a thorough establishment of his affairs, was to proceed with spirit and magnanimity. For he was persuaded, that if he appeared to abate of his dignity in the least article, he would be universally insulted. He therefore quieted the commotions, and put a stop to the rising wars among the barbarians, by marching with the utmost expediency as far as the Danube, where he fought a great battle...”

http://www.fordham.edu/halsall/ancient/plutarch-alexander1.html

"Ancient History Sourcebook: Plutarch: Selections from the Life of Alexander." FORDHAM.EDU. Web. 10 June 2010

Primary Source #3:

“Alexander learned military arts from his father, but he also learned diplomacy; in a period when true diplomacy was little known. (Much like today.) Honorable enemies were treated well, while enemies who had broken oaths or allegiances were treated harshly. Alexander took his lessons with him into Asia, and made good use of them.”

http://www.suite101.com/article.cfm/general_military/19221

"Alexander the Great." Suite101.com: Online Magazine and Writers' Network. Web. 10 June 2010

Argument:

The first primary source shows that at such a young age, Alexander had the desire to take action and to be in control. The second primary source shows that at the early age of twenty, he wanted to take action against the barbarians. Nowhere did he care about the Persians. He simply loved the feeling of conquest and power. Alexander even treated his enemies with respect. This did not mean he wanted retribution to the Persians. It was all about the conquest.

Exam: Question 1

Question: Explain why some scholars have called the Ancient Egyptians a "death obsessed" culture. Do you agree?

Thesis: The Egyptians were considered death obsessed because of their lavish tombs, and total respect for the dead. Deaths were a very big deal, and Egyptians longed for death because of what they believed would be ultimate happiness. They were not obsessed with death, they simply longed for what came after.

Primary Source #1:

“Thou rollest up into the horizon, thou hast set light over the darkness, thou sendest forth air from thy plumes, and thou floodest the Two Lands like the Disk at daybreak. Thy crown penetrateth the height of heaven, thou art the companion of the stars, and the guide of every god. Thou art beneficent in decree and speech, the favoured one of the Great Company of the Gods, and the beloved of the Little Company of the Gods.”

"Papyrus of Ani; Egyptian Book of the Dead [Budge]." African Studies Center, University of Pennsylvania. Web. 10 June 2010.

http://www.africa.upenn.edu/Books/Papyrus_Ani.html

Primary Source #2:

"Now are you a king's son, a prince,

as long as your soul exists, so long will your heart be with you.

Anubis is mindful of you in Busiris,

your soul rejoices in Abydos where your body is happy on the High Hill

Your embalmer rejoices in every place.

Ah, truly, you are the chosen one!

you are made whole in this your dignity which is before me,

Anubis' heart is happy over the work of his hands

and the heart of the Lord of the Divine Hall is thrilled

when he beholds this good god,

Master of those that have been and Ruler over those that are to come.”

"OSIRIS - Death, Afterlife and Eschatology - Egyptian Conceptions of Death - Mircea Eliade, "From Primitives to Zen"" Mircea Eliade. Web. 10 June 2010

http://www.mircea-eliade.com/from-primitives-to-zen/168.html

Primary Source #3:

Hail , gods who dwell in the Hall of the Two Truths,
Who have no evil in your bodies, who live upon maat ,
Who feed upon maat in the presence of Horus
Who lives within his divine disk.
Deliver me from the god Baba,
Who lives on the entrails of the mighty ones on the day of the great judgement.
Grant that I may come to you,
For I have committed no faults,
I have not sinned,
I have not done evil,

I have not lied,
Therefore let nothing evil happen to me.

"Egyptian Book of the Dead, Chapter 125." Washington State University - Pullman, Washington. Web. 10 June 2010.

http://www.wsu.edu/~dee/EGYPT/BOD125.HTM

Explanation of Argument:

The first primary source talks about the wonders of heaven, and how great it will be. The passage describes the human being in “great company of the Gods” and how it is favored. The second passage is describing what has been written on the tombstone of a pharaoh who has died. Clearly, the pharaoh describes great things of this after life and how he will rule again. The third primary source is describing a soul who is being judged. In this, he talks about how he did not do any faults in his life; therefore he strove in his life to get to this final resting place. They were, by the writings above, not obsessed with death, but what the afterlife brought to them.