Thursday, April 22, 2010

Whats so wrong with social orders?

The Medieval Ages had three groups social classes; serfs, clergy, and aristocrats. This was a time period of aristocracy in the Medieval Ages. This simply means “ruler of the best”. The layout of the social order was this: serfs at the bottom, clergy in the middle, and aristocrats at the top. The question is what is so wrong with this? The treatment of each class was so distinct. People knew that you were a serf, member of the clergy, or an aristocrat. Serfs had the harshest treatment of all, being given no mercy. The clergy supported this treatment.
There was a saying that went, “born a serf, and a serf is shall he will die”. This means that you were born into a social class, and had no way of moving up. The serfs were owned by farmers, but unlike slaves, could buy their freedom. The only problem was where would they get the money from? They could only leave the property with the owner’s permission. If serfs were lucky enough to but their freedom, another problem remained. Where would they go? They lacked family members to seek refuge in. For many, they found more comfort in the place they stayed then in the ‘outside world’.
The treatment of the lower class is unbearable. There is a story of a serf and a woman falling in love. The two lovers ran off to get married at a local church and the owner, “asked him to return the two slaves immediately, saying that he had forgiven them”. The priest made the man take an oath that he would never separate the two, not even when the meet their death. The man had done so, but when he got home, told fellow slaves to carve the trunk of a tree and put the slave and woman in the tree trunk. Then, he buried the two alive saying "I have not broken my oath and I have not separated them”. No one took any mercy on these serfs, and their lives were horrible. They were often treated as objects, as if they had no emotion, no worth. Other cases have been reported of the slaves being beaten, sometimes killed by their owners. (Gregory of Tours: Harsh Treatment of Serfs and Slaves, c. 575)
There was a smaller, in between if you will social class of peasants. This class was made of the everyday people that worked in towns. They weren’t as important as clergy and aristocrats and did not own and serfs, but they did live and work freely. Just as serfs, they stayed a peasant their whole life. The peasants carried out everyday work such as farming, mining, shop owners, and so on. They traded for goods, and lived their lives just like average Americans do today. They kept the economy going. This was the social class that most people often forgot about. They didn’t have any special treatments, yet they weren’t abused such as the serfs were.

The social classes are too strictly judged. People’s opportunities are being taken away in life simply on what they were born into. They should have a range of motion, allowing people to, so to speak, move up and down the totem pole. If you work hard in life, you should be rewarded. You slack, consequences should be taken. The treatment of the serfs is so unbelievable, how they treat a person that way. It is downright absurd and no one should have ever been treated that way.

"Medieval Sourcebook: Council of Agde: Concerning Slaves of the Church, 506." FORDHAM.EDU. Web. 23 Apr. 2010.http://www.fordham.edu/halsall/source/506agdechurchslaves.html .

"Medieval Sourcebook: Economic Life." FORDHAM.EDU. Web. 23 Apr. 2010.http://www.fordham.edu/halsall/sbook1j.html .

"Medieval Sourcebook: Gregory of Tours: Harsh Treatment of Serfs and Slaves, C." FORDHAM.EDU. Web. 22 Apr. 2010. . http://www.fordham.edu/halsall/source/575Rauching.html

Wikipedia contributors. "Aristocrates of Athens." Wikipedia, The Free Encyclopedia. Wikipedia, The Free Encyclopedia, 1 Mar. 2010. Web. 23 Apr. 2010.

1 comment:

  1. Nice job finding primary sources, but you only cite one of them in your paper. Use your sources to help back up your argument and spread them throughout your paper, at least one per paragraph.

    ReplyDelete