Thursday, May 13, 2010

Is monarchy more or less effective than democracy?

To look back at an example of a monarchy, the Elizabethan Age could tell it all. Today’s society is all about the democracy. The question is, which is more effective? A monarchy is defined as “supreme power or sovereignty held by a single person” (dictionary.com). In the 16th century, Elizabeth and the Tudor Succession had this sole power. In other words it was a king or queen. Democracy is defines as “government by the people” (dictionary.com). In other words, what the American government is ruled by. This American government of a democracy is much more effective than that of the government ruled by Queen Elizabeth and the Tudor family.
The Elizabethan Age was called that under the rule of Queen Elizabeth from 1558-1604. It was said she had a short temper, and often had to cool herself down by taking a walk. The monarchy she ruled had her as ultimate power. She made all decisions for England and was not afraid of the responsibilities. Like most monarchies that had both a King and Queen, Elizabeth did not want to marry. She told parliament that, "I have already joined myself in marriage to a husband, namely the kingdom of England”. This meant that she did not need a husband to rule over the country, and she would devote herself entirely to her work. The problem with a monarchy is that the people do not have a choice who rules. A monarchy’s power is changed from generation to generation by family members. In most cases, if civilians did not like the King or Queen, they would attempt to overrule.
The government of America today’s society is democracy. In a democracy, citizens vote for the president, and other government officials. They control most of the decisions made when he comes to who holds the most power. Also, the power of the president can be overruled by other branches in the government. This is a much safer, more effective way of making decisions than in the monarchy. The United States has had 44 presidents, citizens voting for a majority of them. The current US president said about becoming president and about what he was going to say to America, “I think that the main task for me in an inauguration speech, and I think this is true for my presidency generally, is to try to capture as best I can the moment that we are in.” Under the presidency of a democracy, we have peacekeepers in almost all countries, put a man on the moon, and bring the United States out of a depression in the 1920’s.
Democracy compared to a monarchy has much more positives too it. The best part of the democracy is the constitution. It keeps laws and orders in line, and does not allow the president to have too much power. For example, in the reign of Mary, Elizabeth’s half sister, she wanted Catholicism to be the only religion practiced in England. Because of this desire, she burned people at the stake if they weren’t Catholics. Most were tried as witches and then burned. With a democratic government, the President would not have the power to do such that. The other branches of the government would overrule this attempt. America also has the justice system and a military to keep things in line along with the constitution. This peaceful law system is much more effective in keeping rule and power, as well as keeping the people happy and safe.


The New York Times - Breaking News, World News & Multimedia. Web. 13 May 2010.

http://www.nytimes.com/

"Quotes: Queen Elizabeth I." Queen Elizabeth I (1533-1603). Web. 13 May 2010. http://www.elizabethi.org/us/quotes/

"Elizabeth I." TudorHistory.org. Web. 13 May 2010. http://www.tudorhistory.org/elizabeth

Dictionary.com Find the Meanings and Definitions of Words at Dictionary.com. Web. 13 May 2010. http://dictionary.reference.com/

1 comment:

  1. This is a good start. I like how you explain the quote from Queen Elizabeth and I think you make a number of good points. However, your thesis is a but jumbled: "This American government of a democracy is much more effective than that of the government ruled by Queen Elizabeth and the Tudor family." and that's something that detracts throughout the paper -- namely, it could have used a serious final edit checking on points of grammar and style.

    ReplyDelete