Question: Do you think Alexander honestly felt like he was avenging Persian wrongs? Or was that just propaganda to mask his goal of conquest?
Thesis: Alexander the Great grew up wanting conquest, as well as wanting power.
Primary Source #1:
While he was yet very young, he entertained the ambassadors from the King of Persia, in the absence of his father, and entering much into conversation with them, gained so much upon them by his affability, and the questions he asked them, which were far from being childish or trifling (for he inquired of them the length of the ways, the nature of the road into inner Asia, the character of their king, how he carried himself to his enemies, and what forces he was able to bring into the field), that they were struck with admiration of him, and looked upon the ability so much famed of Philip to be nothing in comparison with the forwardness and high purpose that appeared thus early in his son. Whenever he heard Philip had taken any town of importance, or won any signal victory, instead of rejoicing at it altogether, he would tell his companions that his father would anticipate everything, and leave him and them no opportunities of performing great and illustrious actions
http://classics.mit.edu/Plutarch/alexandr.html
"The Internet Classics Archive | Alexander by Plutarch." The Internet Classics Archive: 441 Searchable Works of Classical Literature. Web. 10 June 2010.
Primary Source #2:
“[Alexander] was only twenty years old when he succeeded to the crown, and he found the kingdom torn into pieces by dangerous parties and implacable animosities. The barbarous nations, even those that bordered upon Macedonia, could not brook subjection, and they longed for their natural kings... Alexander was of opinion, that the only way to security, and a thorough establishment of his affairs, was to proceed with spirit and magnanimity. For he was persuaded, that if he appeared to abate of his dignity in the least article, he would be universally insulted. He therefore quieted the commotions, and put a stop to the rising wars among the barbarians, by marching with the utmost expediency as far as the Danube, where he fought a great battle...”
http://www.fordham.edu/halsall/ancient/plutarch-alexander1.html
"Ancient History Sourcebook: Plutarch: Selections from the Life of Alexander." FORDHAM.EDU. Web. 10 June 2010
Primary Source #3:
“Alexander learned military arts from his father, but he also learned diplomacy; in a period when true diplomacy was little known. (Much like today.) Honorable enemies were treated well, while enemies who had broken oaths or allegiances were treated harshly. Alexander took his lessons with him into Asia, and made good use of them.”
http://www.suite101.com/article.cfm/general_military/19221
"Alexander the Great." Suite101.com: Online Magazine and Writers' Network. Web. 10 June 2010
Argument:
The first primary source shows that at such a young age, Alexander had the desire to take action and to be in control. The second primary source shows that at the early age of twenty, he wanted to take action against the barbarians. Nowhere did he care about the Persians. He simply loved the feeling of conquest and power. Alexander even treated his enemies with respect. This did not mean he wanted retribution to the Persians. It was all about the conquest.
No comments:
Post a Comment