Question: Were the Vikings "barbarians"?
Thesis: The Vikings were barbarians, destroying everything in their path regardless who it was, or what the intention was.
Primary Source #1:
The work of destruction which the first stream of Northmen wrought on the continent is told in words of despair in what is left of the Frankish Chronicles, for the pagan and greedy invaders seem to have singled out the monasteries for attack and must have destroyed most of the records of their own devastation. A Danish fleet appeared off Frisia in 810, and ten years later another reached the mouth of the Loire, but the systematic and persevering assault did not begin until about 835. From that date till the early years of the following century the Viking ships were almost annual visitors to the coasts and river valleys of Germany andGaul.
http://www.newadvent.org/cathen/11115b.htm
"CATHOLIC ENCYCLOPEDIA: Northmen (Vikings)." NEW ADVENT: Home. Web. 10 June 2010
Primary Source #2:
The Northmen came to Paris with 700 sailing ships, not counting those of smaller size which are commonly called barques. At one stretch the Seine was lined with the vessels for more than two leagues, so that one might ask in astonishment in what cavern the river had been swallowed up, since it was not to be seen. The second day after the fleet of the Northmen arrived under the walls of the city, Siegfried, who was then king only in name but who was in command of the expedition, came to the dwelling of the illustrious bishop. He bowed his head and said: "Gauzelin, have compassion on yourself and on your flock. We beseech you to listen to us, in order that you may escape death. Allow us only the freedom of the city. We will do no harm and we will see to it that whatever belongs either to you or to Odo shall be strictly respected." Count Odo, who later became king, was then the defender of the city. The bishop replied to Siegfried, "Paris has been entrusted to us by the Emperor Charles, who, after God, king and lord of the powerful, rules over almost all the world. He has put it in our care, not at all that the kingdom may be ruined by our misconduct, but that he may keep it and be assured of its peace. If, like us, you had been given the duty of defending these walls, and if you should have done that which you ask us to do, what treatment do you think you would deserve?" Siegfried replied. "I should deserve that my head be cut off and thrown to the dogs. Nevertheless, if you do not listen to my demand, on the morrow our war machines will destroy you with poisoned arrows. You will be the prey of famine and of pestilence and these evils will renew themselves perpetually every year." So saying, he departed and gathered together his comrades.
http://www.fordham.edu/halsall/source/843bertin.html
"Medieval Sourcebook: Three Sources on the Ravages of the Northmen in Frankland, C. 843 - 912."FORDHAM.EDU. Web. 10 June 2010.
Primary Source #3:
According to their custom the Northmen plundered eastern and western Frisia and burned down the town of Dordrecht, with two other villages, before the eyes of Lothair [The Emperor], who was then in the castle of Nimwegen, but could not punish the crime. The Northmen, with their boast filled with immense booty, including both men and goods, returned to their own country.At this same time, as no one can mention or hear without great sadness, the mother of all the churches, the basilica of the apostle Peter, was taken and plundered by the Moors, or Saracens, who had already occupied the region of Beneventum. The Saracens, moreover, slaughtered all the Christians whom they found outside the walls of Rome, either within or without this church. They also carried men and women away prisoners. They tore down, among many others, the altar of the blessed Peter, and their crimes from day to day bring sorrow to Christians. Pope Sergius departed life this year.
http://www.fordham.edu/halsall/source/xanten1.html
"Medieval Sourcebook: Annals of Xanten, 845-853." FORDHAM.EDU. Web. 10 June 2010. v
Argument:
The Vikings came into towns with no warning, slaughtering thousands of people just because they could. Often times they demanded rule of the town. If that was not granted, the town would simply be burnt. As it shows in the third primary source, Christians were a massive target of the Vikings. Churches were burnt to the ground without despair. In some cases, the Vikings even made their way to the New World.
No comments:
Post a Comment