Thursday, June 10, 2010

Exam Question 3

Question: Who is a better model for modern historians: Herodotus or Thucydides? Why?

Thesis: Herodotus was a better model for modern historians because he was the one who first started collecting and organizing his materials.

Primary Source #1:

The customs which I know the Persians to observe are the following: they have no images of the gods, no temples nor altars, and consider the use of them a sign of folly. This comes, I think, from their not believing the gods to have the same nature with men, as the Greeks imagine. Their wont, however, is to ascend the summits of the loftiest mountains, and there to offer sacrifice to Zeus, which is the name they give to the whole circuit of the firmament. They likewise offer to the sun and moon, to the earth, to fire, to water, and to the winds. These are the only gods whose worship has come down to them from ancient times. At a later period they began the worship of Urania, which they borrowed from the Arabians and Assyrians. Mylitta is the name by which the Assyrians know this goddess, whom the Arabians call Alitta, and the Persians Mitra.

http://www.fordham.edu/halsall/ancient/herodotus-persians.html

"Ancient History Sourcebook: Herodotus: Customs of the Persians." FORDHAM.EDU. Web. 10 June 2010.

Primary Source #2:

It must not, however, be supposed that he was at any time a mere student. It is probable that from an early age his inquiring disposition led him to engage in travels, both in Greece and in foreign countries. He traversed Asia Minor and European Greece probably more than once; he visited all the most important islands of the Archipelago-Rhodes, Cyprus, Delos, Paros, Thasos, Samothrace, Crete, Samos, Cythera and Aegina. He undertook the long and perilous journey from Sardis to the Persian capital Susa, visited Babylon, Colchis, and the western shores of the Black Sea as far as the estuary of the Dnieper; he travelled in Scythia and in Thrace, visited Zante and Magna Graecia, explored the antiqmties of Tyre, coasted along the shores of Palestine, saw Ga~a, and made a long stay in Egypt. At the most moderate estimate, his travels covered a space of thirtyone degrees of longitude, or 1700 miles, and twentyfour of latitude, or nearly the same distance. At all the more interesting sites he took up his abode for a time; he examined, he inquired, he made measurements, he accumulated materials. Having in his mind the scheme of his great work, he gave ample time to the elaboration of all its parts, and took care to obtain by personal observation a full knowledge of the various countries.

http://www.fordham.edu/halsall/ancient/eb11-herodotus.html

"Ancient History Sourcebook: 11th Brittanica: Herodotus." FORDHAM.EDU. Web. 10 June 2010.

Primary Source #3:

These are the researches of Herodotus of Halicarnassus, which he publishes, in the hope of thereby preserving from decay the remembrance of what men have done, and of preventing the great and wonderful actions of the Greeks and the Barbarians from losing their due meed of glory; and withal to put on record what were their grounds of feuds. According to the Persians best informed in history, the Phoenicians began to quarrel. This people, who had formerly dwelt on the shores of the Erythraean Sea, having migrated to the Mediterranean and settled in the parts which they now inhabit, began at once, they say, to adventure on long voyages, freighting their vessels with the wares of Egypt and Assyria.

http://classics.mit.edu/Herodotus/history.1.i.html

"The Internet Classics Archive | The History of Herodotus by Herodotus." The Internet Classics Archive: 441 Searchable Works of Classical Literature. Web. 10 June 2010

Argument:

All of these primary sources tell us how Herodotus traveled to find his information. He was one to go out of his comfort zone, and created new forms of history. In many of his writings, Herodotus claims the he knows the information “personally” or that it is his “knowledge”. Many reporters of modern history prefer reading stories written in ways such as Herodotus wrote his.

No comments:

Post a Comment